IBBI Registered Valuer Entity IBBI/RV-E/02/2020/123 · IRDAI category A surveyors+91 97370 33380bd@rakeshnarula.com
CallGet proposal
IBC & insolvency

The Challenges of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code

Published Updated By , Managing Partner

The Challenges of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) is India's single law for insolvency and bankruptcy. It aims to settle unpaid debts fast and get the most from a debtor's assets. In practice it faces hurdles: poor records, pending filings, officers who will not help, and a lack of funds to keep the business running.

Key points

  • Insolvency is a state of financial distress. If it goes on too long, it leads to bankruptcy.
  • Bankruptcy is a legal process that starts with a petition by the debtor.
  • Licensed professionals run the whole process under the IBC.
  • The code's success shows in how workable the plans are and how big a haircut lenders take.

What is insolvency?

Insolvency is a state of financial distress in which someone cannot pay their bills. There is a thin line between insolvency and bankruptcy.

Insolvency can lead to legal action against the firm. Its assets may then be sold to pay off the debt.

It is meant to be a short-term state. If it lasts longer than expected, it leads to bankruptcy. One fix is to change how the loan is repaid, or to write the loan off. If that does not work, the assets are sold to pay the debt. The court appoints an official liquidator. Their first job is to sell all the assets and pay the money to the creditors.

What leads to insolvency?

  • Weak management: poor accounting or people management can lead to insolvency.
  • Rising costs: the business pays more for goods and services, and has to pass that on to customers.
  • Failing to adapt: some firms cannot keep up with what customers now want. A firm that does not move with its industry loses profit and customers.
  • Damages: a firm may have to pay large sums in damages. That hurts its work and its income. With less income, bills go unpaid and lenders ask for their money back.

What is bankruptcy?

Bankruptcy is a legal term. It is used when a person or business cannot repay what they owe.

The process starts with a petition filed by the debtor. All the debtor's assets are measured and valued. They may then be used to repay the debt.

Bankruptcy gives a person or firm the chance to start afresh, because debts that cannot be paid are forgiven. Creditors gain too. They get some of their money back from the assets that can be sold.

What leads to bankruptcy?

  • Finance: this is one of the main problems for small firms. Many owners take loans to keep going. If the lender will not give more funds, the firm may go bankrupt.
  • Poor decisions: weak strategy and hasty choices can make a business fail.
  • Other causes: a poor location, the loss of key staff, lawsuits from rivals, and personal issues such as illness or divorce.

What is the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code?

The IBC is India's bankruptcy law. It brings the old rules together into a single law for insolvency and bankruptcy.

The code protects small investors and makes doing business less of a burden. Licensed professionals run the whole process. They also look after the debtor's assets while it lasts.

The main aim is to revive the firm, or resolve its debts, and get the most from its assets in a limited time. The code also offers a fast-track process.

What challenges does the code face?

Poor records and little help

The code runs into incomplete records, pending compliance work and officers of the debtor who will not cooperate.

Practical hurdles for resolution professionals

Resolution professionals (IRPs) face problems with infrastructure and logistics as they do their core duties. They must go to the tribunals and wait for directions. That makes it hard to finish each task in the set time.

A lack of funds

IRPs need working capital to run the debtor's business as a going concern. They must keep raising money to meet its daily needs.

Often they go to the firm's existing lenders for more funds. The money is needed to clear debts, pay staff their pending salaries and restart work that was put on hold.

How is the code's success measured?

It can be judged by:

  • How workable the resolution plans are
  • How big a haircut the financial creditors have to take
  • How flexible buyers are in offering deals that can save the company

Operational creditors have only a small role in the process.

Who makes the decisions?

A committee of creditors is formed during the process. It is the driving force. Every decision the IRP takes is approved by the creditors on the committee.

The IRP takes over the running of the company. The powers of the existing board of directors are suspended.

Read more on the role of insolvency resolution professionals.

What does the code mean for stakeholders?

The code looks at the interests of all stakeholders, including financial and operational creditors. A key benefit is that the process stays confidential throughout.

But there is a risk. If the process fails and the company goes into liquidation, the stakeholders get nothing.

On the positive side, the code is likely to change how borrowers and lenders behave. It also takes account of the smallest stakeholders, and even employees.

What is the bottom line?

If it is carried out in an orderly way, the IBC can benefit everyone involved. For help with insolvency and bankruptcy matters, see RNC's CIRP valuation service or contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Why do IBC cases exceed timelines?

Three things cause it: court fights, delays in admitting the case and slow flow of data.

What is the difference between insolvency and bankruptcy?

In India, insolvency most often means a company going through the IBC process. Bankruptcy is the word used for one person or a partnership firm.

Sources and standards

The regulators and standard setters whose rules apply to this topic. Rules change, so check the current text before relying on it.

Get a quote

Request a valuation proposal

Tell us what needs valuing and why. You will hear back from a partner, not a sales desk.

  • Scoped proposal with fee and timeline, usually within one business day
  • Conflict check and NDA before any data changes hands
  • Reports signed under IBBI registration IBBI/RV-E/02/2020/123

Tell us about the assignment

Takes under a minute. All fields help us scope accurately.

    Service interested in *

    Your details stay confidential and are used only to prepare your proposal.