
We valued a developer's half-built commercial project, even though key data did not reconcile. We used the discounted cash flow (DCF) method. We counted only cash flows we could verify: sales of unsold units at today's rates in, and the cost to finish and sell out. We left out receivables we could not reconcile. The result was fair to both the lender and the client.
Key points
- The developer was an NPA, and its records were incomplete.
- Receivables and the sold and unsold unit lists did not add up.
- DCF worked because it rests on real expected cash flows, not on market comparisons.
- Use only what you can verify, check the site and record every assumption.
Who was the client?
A well-known Indian property developer had been classified as a non-performing asset (NPA). Its portfolio included:
- Finished homes and office towers, with receivables and unsold stock
- A commercial property still under construction
- Development rights over a land parcel with tenants
- A separate, empty landholding
This case focuses on the half-built commercial project, where incomplete records were the main hurdle.
What were the challenges?
- Receivables did not match: amounts owed by buyers did not match agreement values or payments received.
- Stock did not add up: the lists of sold and unsold units did not match the reported total. The stock data could not be trusted at face value.
This raised two key questions:
- How do you value a half-built project without accurate data?
- How do you value finished projects with unsold units and unreliable receivables?
These problems are common with distressed assets. A reliable value must cut through the doubt to protect both the company and its creditors. Read about when a company needs a valuation.
What is DCF, and why use it here?
DCF estimates the value of a project today by forecasting its future cash flows and discounting them back. It rests on a simple idea: money today is worth more than the same money later, because it can earn a return.
DCF is widely used for capital budgeting, investment analysis and project valuation. It allows scenario and sensitivity tests. And it works even when market comparables are scarce.
Here, there were no direct market comparisons and no clean data. DCF was the best fit because it:
- Focuses on real, expected cash in and out
- Handles uncertainty through the discount rate
- Gives a clear, scenario-based view for everyone involved
How did we apply DCF?
Cash in: we included only the sale value of unsold units at current market rates, plus reliable future forecasts. We left out receivables from sold units, because that data was unclear.
Cash out: we included the cost to finish the unbuilt areas, based on site checks, and the marketing and sales cost for unsold stock. We left out speculative costs.
Discounting: we used a discount rate that reflects current market risk and the developer's profile. We brought all cash flows back to today's value.
Adjustments: we deducted verified amounts already received from sold units. We left out receivables we could not reconcile, to avoid overvaluing.
Review: several internal reviews made sure the figures were realistic, cautious and defensible.
What are the strengths and limits of DCF?
| Strengths | Limits |
|---|---|
| Flexible: models many scenarios and markets | Depends on estimates of cash flow and discount rates |
| Versatile: works for many assets | Sensitive to market and economic change |
| Clear: shows the reasoning behind each assumption | Best cross-checked with other methods |
How did we solve the case?
- Half-built project: we included only reliable, observable cash in and confirmed, necessary cash out.
- Finished assets: we valued unsold units at current rates and left out unreliable receivables.
The final value was neither too high nor too low, protecting both the lender and the client.
What are the lessons?
- Do not force data to fit. If records do not reconcile, use only what you can verify.
- Check the site. Physical checks on progress make the model stronger.
- Record every assumption. Openness builds trust and supports compliance.
- Use other methods too. DCF is powerful, but back it up with other approaches where you can.
To choose the discount rate, weigh market benchmarks, project risk and investor expectations, and record your reasoning.
What is the bottom line?
When data is patchy, a cautious DCF remains a gold standard for real estate valuation. With professional rigour, even distressed projects can be valued accurately.
This case was led by Sahil R. Narula, Managing Partner at RNC. He is based in Mumbai and specialises in project valuation, financial modelling and distressed assets. Need help with a complex valuation? See our real estate valuation service, or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Why use DCF for an unfinished project?+
It brings three things into one model: the value of the finished project, the cost and time to get there, and the risk on the way.
How were data gaps handled?+
We wrote down each assumption. Each one was based on site checks and market evidence. We then tested them with what-if cases.
Sources and standards
The regulators and standard setters whose rules apply to this topic. Rules change, so check the current text before relying on it.