Manufacturing company valuation joins two kinds of work. One is a business valuation. We most often use DCF and market multiples for it. The other is the value of the factories, plant and stock. Makers of goods often need more than that. They need fixed asset registers. They need componentization under Ind AS 16. They need impairment tests. And they need reinstatement values for insurance.
When does fmcg & manufacturing need a valuation?
| Trigger | What is needed | Rule or source |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase or sale of a manufacturer | Enterprise value and technical due diligence | Transaction |
| Ind AS reporting | Componentization, impairment and fair value | Ind AS 16, 36, 113 |
| Audit | Physical check of assets and FAR | CARO |
| Insurance renewal | Reinstatement value | Policy terms |
Which valuation method fits?
| Asset or situation | Approach we use |
|---|---|
| Running business | DCF and market multiples |
| Factories and plant | Depreciated replacement cost |
| Brands | Relief-from-royalty |
| Inventory | Net realisable value |
How do you value a bottler across two countries?
Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages asked us to value its assets. They were in India and Nepal. The work was for a review by its managers. We used the same basis for each plant and for both countries.
Why componentize a plant?
For PI Industries we split large assets into parts. Each part has its own useful life. Depreciation then matched how the plant really wears. Parts that were swapped could also be booked the right way.
When does a manufacturer need an impairment test?
It needs one when profits fall or plant sits idle. It also needs one when the tech moves on. We did impairment work for three firms. They were Yokohama India, Tata Automotive Stampings and APL Apollo. We tested what each asset could earn back against its value in the books. Their auditors used the results.
Pitfalls we see most often
- A FAR that does not match the shop floor. A physical check finds the gaps.
- One useful life for a whole plant. Parts wear at different rates.
- Insuring at book value. The cost to replace is usually higher.
- Leaving out idle capacity. It may be a sign of impairment.