Steel industry valuation usually rests on the plant: blast furnaces, DRI kilns, rolling mills and captive power. A running plant is valued with the income and cost approaches. A stressed or idle plant is valued asset by asset on depreciated replacement cost. We then test three cases: a restart, a sale as a going concern and a piece-by-piece sale.
When does steel & metals need a valuation?
| Trigger | What is needed | Rule or source |
|---|---|---|
| Steel or metal plant goes into CIRP | Fair value and liquidation value for each asset class | CIRP Regulations, 2016 |
| Insurance renewal for a large plant | Reinstatement value of plant and buildings | Policy terms |
| Metal prices fall or capacity sits idle | Impairment test of the CGU | Ind AS 36 |
| Lender restructuring | Asset and enterprise values | Lender policy |
| Sale of a plant or unit | Enterprise value and technical due diligence | Transaction |
Which valuation method fits?
| Asset or situation | Approach we use |
|---|---|
| Operating integrated plant | DCF on spreads and how much of the capacity is used, cross-checked with replacement cost |
| Idle or partly running plant | Depreciated replacement cost, with a restart case and a piece-by-piece sale case |
| Captive power inside the plant | Valued with cases for what it depends on (see the Power playbook) |
| Stocks of raw material and finished steel | Net realisable value at today’s prices |
Why does a steel plant in CIRP need an asset-by-asset approach?
When a steel plant enters CIRP, its past earnings mostly show the distress. They do not show what the plant can do. Bidders price the furnaces, mills and utilities they would take over. They also price the cost to restart them. So we build the value up from the assets, which our engineers inspect. We show the restart case and the piece-by-piece case side by side for the committee of creditors. Read the steel plant case study.
What if sanctions or markets, not the plant, caused the failure?
A maker of goods became insolvent after economic sanctions cut it off from its market. The plant itself was sound. So the key question for lenders was how to split the value of the plant from the lost access to its market. Read the case study.
How do you insure a plant spread across India?
For Hindalco Industries we did a reinstatement valuation for insurance. It covered assets across India. The sums insured then matched the cost to rebuild each site at today’s prices. They no longer leaned on old book values.
Pitfalls we see most often
- Using book values for insurance. The cost to replace a metal plant moves with steel and equipment prices.
- Leaving out restart cost. Idle furnaces and mills need relining, repairs and approvals before they can run.
- Missing what the plant shares. Power, oxygen and water plants are often shared.
- Overlooking old technology. Older plant has functional obsolescence even when it still runs.

