IBBI Registered Valuer Entity IBBI/RV-E/02/2020/123 · IRDAI category A surveyors+91 97370 33380bd@rakeshnarula.com
CallGet proposal
M&A & corporate finance

Yes Bank Case Explained (2025): Key Lessons for Investors & Regulators

Published Updated By , Partner, Securities & Financial Assets

Yes Bank Case Explained (2025): Key Lessons for Investors & Regulators

Yes Bank failed because it lent heavily to stressed borrowers, under-reported bad loans, had weak governance and could not raise fresh capital. On 5th March 2020, the RBI put the bank under a 30-day moratorium. Under the rescue plan, SBI bought a 49% stake at Rs 10 per share, for shares with a face value of Rs 2. The case is still a warning for investors, regulators and banks.

A moratorium is a delay or pause in an activity or a law. In a legal setting, it means a law is put on hold for a time.

Key points

  • Yes Bank's loans grew nearly four times between 2014 and 2019, much faster than its deposits.
  • Gross NPAs doubled between April and September 2019 to Rs 17,134 crore.
  • Exposure to IL&FS and DHFL, weak governance and deposit flight deepened the crisis.
  • Depositors could withdraw only Rs 50,000 during the moratorium, except in emergencies.

How did Yes Bank grow, and how did it fall?

The bank was set up by top bankers. They were Ashok Kapur, former country head of ABN Amro Bank, Harkirat Singh, former country head of Deutsche Bank, and Rana Kapoor, former corporate finance head of ANZ Grindlays Bank.

Yes Bank got its licence in 2004 and listed through an IPO in 2005. It grew slowly and steadily at first. The decline began when it lent to stressed borrowers, including the Anil Ambani Group and Dewan Housing Finance Corporation Ltd.

As one RNC financial valuation expert put it, the case shows how weak governance and unchecked lending can shake a whole financial system. For investors, the key is to spot red flags early.

On March 31, 2014, the bank's loans stood at Rs 55,633 crore and its deposits at Rs 74,192 crore. By September 30, 2019, loans had grown nearly four times, to Rs 2.25 trillion. Business Standard reported that deposits grew less than three times, to Rs 2.10 trillion.

Asset quality worsened. The RBI found large under-reported stressed assets. The tipping point came when independent director Uttam Prakash Agarwal resigned from the board.

Why did Yes Bank collapse?

The main reason was that the bank could not raise capital to cover likely loan losses. That led to rating downgrades, investors invoking bond covenants and depositors pulling money out. Here are the other causes.

1. Bad loans (NPAs)

The bank kept running well even after Ashok Kapur died in the Mumbai terror attacks and his family went to court. When the government changed in 2014, the bank was near its peak, with NPAs of 0.31 percent. In 2017-18, its value crossed Rs 1 lakh crore.

But the RBI's asset quality reviews in 2017 and 2018 exposed bad loans and serious governance lapses. The bank also struggled to raise capital. Its gross NPAs doubled between April and September 2019, to Rs 17,134 crore.

2. The NBFC crisis

Trouble grew after the collapse of Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services (IL&FS), which then spread to Dewan Housing Finance Limited (DHFL). Media reports put the bank's exposure to IL&FS and DHFL at 11.5% in September 2019. By April 2019, it had already put about Rs 10,000 crore of loans on a watch list, as likely bad loans over the next 12 months.

3. Governance

The RBI looked closely at the bank's governance after independent director Uttam Prakash Agrawal resigned. He cited falling governance standards and compliance failures. In 2018-19, the bank under-reported NPAs by Rs 3,277 crore. The RBI sent former Deputy Governor Rama Subramanian Gandhi to the board. Rana Kapoor was asked to step down as chief executive in January 2019.

4. Heavy withdrawals

Depositors steadily withdrew money, which hurt the balance sheet. By the end of September 2019, deposits were Rs 2.09 trillion. Too much liquidity and too little investment were the two main reasons.

5. False comfort

The RBI said it was working with management to strengthen the balance sheet and cash position. Yes Bank told the RBI it was in talks with several investors. In reality, no investor made a firm offer of the money the bank needed.

6. Investors were not serious

In a February 2020 stock exchange filing, the bank said it was in talks with some private equity firms. The RBI said investors met its senior officials but put in no capital. They were not serious about rescuing the bank.

What happened next?

On the RBI's application, the government ordered a moratorium on Yes Bank until 3rd April 2020.

How were depositors affected?

During the moratorium, the bank could not pay any depositor more than Rs 50,000 without written RBI permission.

  • The limit applied per depositor, however many accounts they held.
  • Any dues owed to the bank were adjusted before a withdrawal.

In an emergency, the RBI allowed withdrawals above Rs 50,000, up to 5 lakhs, for:

  • Medical treatment of the depositor
  • Higher education in India or abroad
  • Wedding or other ceremony costs
  • Other emergencies

What did the government do?

  • The RBI set a month-long moratorium, due to end on 3rd April.
  • Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman told depositors the RBI was working for a quick fix.
  • The RBI was to set out a restructuring plan within 30 days to protect depositors.
  • A new board would review the roles of key managers.
  • Staff would keep the same terms and pay for at least one year.
  • SBI would take up to a 49% stake at no less than Rs 10 per share with a face value of Rs 2.
  • SBI could not cut its stake below 26% for 3 years from the capital infusion.

The RBI did its best to give some relief to depositors with real emergencies.

The government also planned to bring back the Financial Resolution and Deposit Insurance (FRDI) Bill 2017, with changes, as the Financial Sector Development and Regulation (FSDR) Bill 2019. The new bill aims to prevent bank failures. It drops the "bail-in" clause, which would have let failing banks use depositors' money to stay afloat.

What is the way forward?

This was the third big bank failure. For the first time, the government used a model where a state bank buys and holds the failed bank's shares. SBI and the RBI did thorough due diligence on Yes Bank. They also negotiated with other investors to buy into the new rights issue.

The priority is to get the bank running again quickly, protect its deposit base and rebuild trust that it can recover.

Read more on lessons from valuation crashes.

Who is RNC?

RNC values fixed and current assets for M&A, bank lending, disputes, insolvency, financial reporting and compliance. We are also an IRDA licensed category 'A' insurance surveyor and loss assessor. See our valuation for banking or contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What did RBI do in the Yes Bank case?

It put the bank under a moratorium and replaced the board. It then approved a rescue scheme in which SBI and other banks put in money.

What is the lesson for valuation?

Loan books and the assets that back them must be valued as they really are. If asset quality is overstated, it shows up as losses in the end.

Sources and standards

The regulators and standard setters whose rules apply to this topic. Rules change, so check the current text before relying on it.

Get a quote

Request a valuation proposal

Tell us what needs valuing and why. You will hear back from a partner, not a sales desk.

  • Scoped proposal with fee and timeline, usually within one business day
  • Conflict check and NDA before any data changes hands
  • Reports signed under IBBI registration IBBI/RV-E/02/2020/123

Tell us about the assignment

Takes under a minute. All fields help us scope accurately.

    Service interested in *

    Your details stay confidential and are used only to prepare your proposal.