The first ESOP grants at a startup need two values. One is the fair market value of the shares, used for tax when staff exercise. The other is the fair value of the options, used in the accounts. Get both right at the start. This avoids TDS and accounting problems that tend to show up at the next funding round.
How it usually unfolds
A Series A company wants to grant options to its first twenty staff.
We value the shares as at the grant date. We model the fair value of the options from the volatility, the expected term and the exercise price. For tax at exercise, our partner supplies the right merchant-banker report.
Staff get a fair grant. The company has clean records when the next investor’s team comes to check.
Illustrative scenario drawn from the kinds of mandates RNC handles. It does not describe a specific client.
What changes the value
| Decision point | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Grant date | Values must be as at the grant date, not reused from an earlier one. |
| Option model inputs | The volatility and term you assume need support. |
| Tax at exercise | FMV must be current when staff exercise. |
What to have ready
- ESOP scheme document
- Cap table and accounts
- Grant schedule
- Recent funding papers