Between funding rounds, common shares in a late-stage startup are rarely worth the last preferred round price. Valuers split the equity value across share classes with a waterfall or an option-pricing method. This takes account of who gets paid first on a sale. Where it fits, they then apply a discount because the shares are hard to sell.
How it usually unfolds
A unicorn plans a buyback so early staff can cash in some shares. The last round priced the preferred shares at a high value.
We value the company as a whole. Then we model how that value flows to each class of shares under the preference terms. In each case, common shares get what is left once the preferred holders are paid.
The buyback price is fair to staff and holds up for tax and the accounts. See the real case study below.
Illustrative scenario drawn from the kinds of mandates RNC handles. It does not describe a specific client. The case study below is a real engagement.
What changes the value
| Decision point | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Liquidation preferences | These move value from common holders to preferred holders. |
| How value is split | Waterfall or OPM: the choice depends on the exit that is expected. |
| Ease of sale | Common shares that are hard to sell may need a discount. |
What to have ready
- Shareholders’ agreement and articles
- Cap table by class
- Latest accounts and forecasts
- Papers from the recent round
