IBBI Registered Valuer Entity IBBI/RV-E/02/2020/123 · IRDAI category A surveyors+91 97370 33380bd@rakeshnarula.com
CallGet proposal
Business & share valuation

Purpose of Valuation: 12 Key Reasons, Mandatory Triggers & Who Needs It in India 2025

Published Updated By , Partner, Securities & Financial Assets

Purpose of Valuation: 12 Key Reasons, Mandatory Triggers & Who Needs It in India 2025

The purpose of valuation is to find what a business, asset, security or project is worth on a given date. That figure helps people decide whether to buy, sell, invest, tax, regulate or restructure it.

In India, valuation is not just a strategy tool. The law asks for it in over 25 situations. These fall under the Companies Act 2013, the Income Tax Act, FEMA, SEBI rules and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. The report must come from an IBBI-registered valuer or a SEBI-recognised professional. Which one depends on the deal.

Key points

  • The purpose decides the method, the standard of value, who can sign and which law applies.
  • A report made for one purpose cannot be used for another.
  • This guide covers 12 main purposes, with a full table of legal triggers.
  • Skipping a required valuation can bring tax demands, FEMA penalties or a rejected merger.

Why does the purpose come first?

Most people see valuation as a number: what is this company worth? Valuers and regulators start somewhere else. Their first question is: what is the valuation for?

The purpose decides everything else:

  • The method: DCF for fundraising, NAV for asset-heavy firms, market multiples for M&A.
  • The standard of value: fair value for IBC, fair market value for income tax, market value for SEBI.
  • Who can sign: an IBBI-registered valuer, a SEBI merchant banker or a CA.
  • Which law applies: the Companies Act, FEMA, IBC, Income Tax Act or SEBI rules.
  • Whether it holds up: a report made for one purpose cannot be used for another.

So a fundraising report cannot be filed with the tax department. An IBC report cannot be used for FEMA. A CA's tax report may not be accepted by SEBI.

To see how methods change with purpose, read our guide to business valuation approaches.

What are the 12 main purposes of valuation?

1. Mergers, acquisitions and business combinations

When firms merge or one buys another, valuation sets the fair worth of what is exchanged. Neither side should overpay or undersell. Regulators, auditors and small shareholders also need a figure from an independent valuer.

In M&A, valuation sets:

  • The purchase price or enterprise value
  • The share swap ratio: how many shares of Company B one share of Company A is worth
  • The fairness opinion: is the price fair to all shareholders, including minorities?
  • Goodwill for post-deal accounts (Ind AS 103)

The law: under Section 232(2)(d) of the Companies Act 2013, a registered valuer's report is required before the NCLT approves a merger. SEBI also requires fairness opinions for listed open offers and schemes under the Takeover Code.

If you skip it: the NCLT often rejects schemes when the swap ratio lacks an independent valuer's report. Courts have held such ratios to be presumed unfair to minorities.

2. Raising equity from investors

You may raise equity from angels, VCs, PE funds or strategic investors. Each time, valuation anchors the deal. It sets what share of the company the investor gets for their money. Read about the methods of share valuation.

It prevents two costly outcomes:

  • Founders giving away too much by accepting too low a value
  • Investors overpaying for a value the results cannot support

Angel tax: under Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income Tax Act, shares issued above the fair market value (FMV) set under Rule 11UA were taxed as income. DPIIT-registered startups were exempt. Angel tax has since been abolished for share issues from 1 April 2025. But reports remain vital for past rounds and for FEMA. See the net asset method of share valuation.

Who does it: for income tax, a CA or SEBI merchant banker (Rule 11UA). For FEMA, when a foreign investor is involved, a SEBI Category-I merchant banker or registered valuer.

3. ESOPs

An ESOP gives staff the right to buy shares later at a set price (the exercise price). Both that price and the accounting cost must rest on a certified valuation.

RequirementPurposeWho does it
Fair market value of sharesSets the exercise price; avoids tax on issueCA or SEBI merchant banker (Rule 11UA)
Fair value of the optionSets the cost in the P&L (Ind AS 102)Registered valuer or certified actuary

ESOPs need a fresh valuation every year. Share value changes with each funding round, revenue milestone or market shift.

2025 update: SEBI now lets startup founders keep their ESOPs after an IPO. That makes accurate option values matter from before the IPO through to listing.

Read our ESOP valuation guide for Indian startups.

4. IPO pricing

Before a company lists on the NSE or BSE, its issue price must be backed by valuation work. This usually appears in the Red Herring Prospectus.

In an IPO, valuation sets:

  • The price band for book building
  • Comparisons with listed peer multiples
  • Enterprise value from a DCF
  • The case for a premium or discount to peers

SEBI rule: the prospectus must explain the basis of the issue price, with peer comparisons and benchmarks. A separate report is not always filed publicly, but the banker's price band rests on formal valuation work.

5. Income tax and capital gains

Valuation runs through Indian tax law, for both company deals and personal transfers.

Tax ruleTriggerValuation needed for
Section 50CASelling unlisted shares below FMVDeemed capital gains on the shortfall
Rule 11UAShare issue above FMV (angel tax)The taxable amount
Section 56(2)(x)Buying shares below FMVDeemed gift income on the discount
Section 9(1)(i)Indirect transfer of foreign company sharesFMV of Indian business assets
Section 92CTransfer pricing between related partiesThe arm's length price
Section 80IACDPIIT startup tax benefitsA valuation certificate for eligibility

Who does it: a practising CA or a SEBI merchant banker. The Income Tax Act does not name IBBI registered valuers, but their reports are accepted as supporting evidence.

6. FEMA and foreign investment

Each cross-border equity deal with an Indian company in it needs a certified valuation. That covers FDI into India and ODI out of India.

DealFEMA rule
FDI: shares issued to a foreign investorCannot be issued below FMV
Resident sells to a non-residentPrice must be at or above FMV
Non-resident sells to a residentPrice must be at or below FMV
Sweat equity or ESOPs for foreign staffFMV on the exercise date
Convertible instruments (CCPS, OCDs)FMV at issue and at conversion
ODI: Indian firm investing abroadFMV of the overseas company

Who does it: for deals up to USD 5 million, a CA or cost accountant. Above USD 5 million, or for share swaps, a SEBI Category-I merchant banker. The report is usually valid for 90 days.

7. IBC insolvency (CIRP and liquidation)

A company may enter the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) or liquidation under the IBC 2016. In both cases the law asks for a valuation. It sets the floor for what creditors recover.

Value typeMeaningHow it is used
Fair valueValue in an orderly sale between willing partiesCreditors judge resolution plans against it
Liquidation valueValue in a forced, time-bound saleThe minimum; plans cannot offer creditors less

Regulation 27: the resolution professional must appoint two IBBI-registered valuers. Both must be independent. This must be done within 7 days of the day the professional takes charge. Each sets fair and liquidation value. The average of the two becomes the official figure.

From April 2026: all IBC valuations must follow International Valuation Standards (IVS), under IBBI's April 1, 2026 circular.

Only IBBI-registered valuers can do IBC work. SEBI merchant bankers and CAs are not accepted. See our guide to valuation under IBC.

8. Financial reporting under Ind AS

Firms on Ind AS or IFRS must measure and disclose the fair value of many assets and liabilities. This is a recurring task, not a one-off.

StandardWhat needs valuingHow often
Ind AS 103Goodwill and intangibles in business combinationsAt the acquisition date
Ind AS 36Impairment tests of goodwill and long-lived assetsYearly, and on trigger events
Ind AS 113Fair value of financial instrumentsAt each reporting date
Ind AS 109Instruments at fair value through P&L or OCIOngoing
Ind AS 116Right-of-use assets for leasesAt the start and on changes
Ind AS 102Share-based payments (ESOP fair value)At grant date, yearly

Who does it: registered valuers under the Companies Act for assets, goodwill and intangibles. Actuaries or certified analysts for financial instruments. More and more, auditors ask for independent reports when a fair value is hard to set. See valuation for impairment testing.

9. Bank loans and debt restructuring

When firms borrow, lenders value the collateral. This sets loan eligibility, loan-to-value (LTV) ratios and risk.

AssetPurposeHow often
Commercial or industrial propertyMortgage securityAt the start, then yearly
Plant and machineryCollateral checkAt the start, then as needed
Enterprise valueProject finance or LBO underwritingAt the start
Stressed asset (NPA)Recovery valueBefore sale to an ARC

Bad loans: a loan may turn into an NPA. The bank then orders a valuation. It does so before it sells the loan to an Asset Reconstruction Company (ARC) or acts under SARFAESI. The value sets the reserve price.

RBI rule: banks must revalue properties regularly. That means yearly for stressed accounts and every 3 years for standard accounts. See valuation for banking.

10. Exit, sale and succession

For owners planning to sell, list or hand over, valuation gives an objective base for planning and talks.

  • Sale to a buyer or investor: sets an asking price backed by evidence, not gut feel. Negotiating without one is like selling a house without an appraisal.
  • Listing: knowing your value 2–3 years before an IPO lets you drive the metrics that win a better exit multiple.
  • Family succession or gifts: a valuation avoids disputes and records fair market value for tax.
  • Co-founder buy-sell agreements: agree the valuation method at the start. This stops bitter fights when a founder leaves.

How often: every 18–24 months while you are growing fast. Also before any big event, such as fundraising, M&A talks, a partner exit or succession.

11. Litigation, disputes and arbitration

People fight over who owns what, what an asset is worth or who is owed money. They do so in court, in arbitration or before a regulator. In each case an expert valuation is the base of the case.

DisputeWhat valuation settles
Minority shareholder oppression (NCLT)Fair value of shares for a buyout
Founder disputesThe value of each party's stake
Divorce (family court)The value of a spouse's business interest
Insurance claimsReinstatement or market value of damaged assets
Transfer pricing (ITAT)Arm's length price of related-party deals
Trademark or IP infringementThe economic value of the IP
Land acquisition compensation (NCLAT)Market value of the land

Dispute reports must be well documented, with every assumption explained and the method clear. The other side will challenge every number. RNC builds its reports to stand up to tribunal and court scrutiny. See valuation for litigation and dispute resolution.

12. Insurance (reinstatement value)

Every factory, plant and business asset should be insured at its reinstatement value. That is the cost to rebuild or replace it at today's prices.

The Average Clause is a trap for under-insured firms. Say a factory is insured for ₹15 crore, but it would cost ₹23 crore to rebuild. A fire causes ₹8 crore of damage. The insurer pays:

Claim paid = Loss × (Sum insured ÷ Actual replacement cost) = ₹8 crore × (₹15 Cr ÷ ₹23 Cr) = ₹8 crore × 0.652 = ₹5.2 crore

The business bears ₹2.8 crore of a loss it thought was covered, just because the value was never updated.

How often: yearly for assets with fast-rising prices, such as construction, steel and electrical equipment. Every 2–3 years for stable assets. Read our guide to valuation for insurance.

When is valuation legally required in India?

SituationLawRequired?Who can value
Preferential share issueCompanies Act 2013, S.62(1)(c)YesIBBI registered valuer
Merger or amalgamationCompanies Act 2013, S.232(2)(d)YesIBBI registered valuer
Demerger or spin-offCompanies Act 2013, S.232YesIBBI registered valuer
Share buybackCompanies Act 2013, S.68YesIBBI registered valuer
Minority squeeze-outCompanies Act 2013, S.236(2)YesIBBI registered valuer
ESOP exercise priceCompanies Act 2013 / SEBI rulesYesCA or SEBI merchant banker
Angel tax protection (share issue)Income Tax Act, Rule 11UAYes, if above FMVCA or SEBI merchant banker
Capital gains on transfer below FMVIncome Tax Act, S.50CAYesCA or SEBI merchant banker
FDI share issueFEMA, NDI Rules 2019YesCA or SEBI merchant banker
Transfer from resident to non-residentFEMA, NDI Rules 2019YesCA or SEBI merchant banker
CIRP fair and liquidation valueIBC 2016, Regulation 27YesIBBI registered valuer only
Liquidation asset valuationIBC 2016, Regulation 34YesIBBI registered valuer only
Voluntary liquidationIBC 2016, S.59(3)(b)(ii)YesIBBI registered valuer
IPO price bandSEBI ICDRYesSEBI merchant banker + registered valuer
Open offer for thinly traded sharesSEBI SAST 2011 (Dec 2025 change)YesIBBI registered valuer (new)
Preferential allotment (listed firm)SEBI ICDR, Regulation 165YesIBBI registered valuer
AIF portfolio valuationSEBI AIF Circular 2023Yes, yearlyIndependent registered valuer
REIT or InvIT assetsSEBI REIT/InvIT rulesYes, yearlyIndependent registered valuer
Delisting floor priceSEBI Delisting rulesYesIBBI registered valuer
Goodwill impairment testInd AS 36Yes, yearlyRegistered valuer, or internal with review
Purchase price allocationInd AS 103YesRegistered valuer
Transfer pricingIncome Tax Act, S.92CYesCA or accountant
Bank collateral (property)RBI guidelinesYes, periodicallyIBBI registered valuer
Insurance reinstatementInsurance practiceStrongly advisedRegistered valuer

December 2025 update: SEBI's change to the Takeover Code (SAST rules) now asks for IBBI-registered valuers to price open offers for thinly traded shares. Merchant bankers alone are no longer enough. It is the biggest shift in India's valuation rules since the registered valuer system began in 2019.

Who needs a valuation, and when?

Founders and promoters: when you raise equity, issue ESOPs or plan an exit. Also when you set up a co-founder buy-sell deal, face a tax check or pass shares to family. Most often missed: founders learn they needed a valuation only after a tax notice under Rule 11UA or Section 56(2)(x). Get one before every share issue.

CFOs and finance heads: for Ind AS reporting (goodwill impairment, PPA, fair value of instruments). Also for papers to raise funds that investors will trust, for debt restructuring, for FEMA filings and for yearly ESOP accounting. Most often missed: the yearly Ind AS 36 goodwill test. Many firms use internal estimates. SEBI and auditors now flag undocumented tests as governance lapses.

Banks and creditors: when you make secured loans, review stressed accounts or sell NPAs to ARCs. Also when you sit on an IBC creditors' committee, or judge resolution plans against fair and liquidation value.

Resolution professionals and liquidators: valuation is your first legal step. Regulation 27 requires two registered valuers within 7 days of your appointment. Missing this risks IBBI action. The report anchors the whole CIRP.

PE funds, ARCs and strategic investors: for due diligence and CIRP bids. For what a stressed asset can recover. For yearly portfolio valuations under SEBI AIF rules. And to back up your prices to your LPs.

Legal and compliance teams: for expert evidence before the NCLT, ITAT or High Courts. Also for fairness opinions, merger scheme papers, related-party rules and transfer pricing reviews.

Which professional can sign for each law?

This is one of the most misunderstood parts of Indian valuation law. Each law names its own professional. Use the wrong one, and your report may be rejected.

LawWho can valueNot accepted
Companies Act 2013, S.247IBBI registered valuerCA or merchant banker alone
IBC 2016IBBI registered valuerCA, merchant banker
FEMA / RBI cross-borderCA, SEBI Cat-I merchant banker, cost accountantIBBI valuer alone
Income Tax / Rule 11UAPractising CA, SEBI merchant bankerIBBI valuer alone
SEBI IPO, open offer, preferential allotmentIBBI registered valuer (after the Dec 2025 SAST change) + merchant bankerCA alone
SEBI AIF portfolioIndependent registered valuerThe fund manager's own valuation
REIT / InvIT assetsIndependent registered valuerInternal valuation
Ind AS reportingRegistered valuer or actuary for complex cases; internal for simple ones

The safest rule: when in doubt, hire an IBBI registered valuer entity registered in all three asset classes: plant and machinery, land and building, and securities and financial assets. One engagement then covers the widest range of rules.

What happens if you skip a required valuation?

  • Tax notice: for past issues above FMV without a report, the excess is taxed as income, plus interest at 12% a year from the deal date. This often surfaces years later in an assessment.
  • FEMA penalty: issuing shares to a foreign investor below FMV breaks FEMA pricing rules. Penalties include compounding fees, forced reversal and limits on future foreign investment.
  • NCLT rejection: merger schemes without a registered valuer's swap ratio report are rejected at admission. Refiling adds months.
  • IBC action: if an RP fails to appoint valuers within 7 days, IBBI can start disciplinary action. In contested cases, bidders can use the lapse to challenge the whole process.
  • Qualified audit: if auditors lack evidence for goodwill tests or PPA, they qualify their report. For listed firms, that draws SEBI scrutiny.
  • Investor disputes: you need a pre-money value you can defend. With none, a later down round can show the first value had no base, and that starts fights.

How often should you get a valuation?

Stage or situationHow often
Pre-revenue startupAt every funding round
Early stage (Seed to Series A)Every 12–18 months, and before every round
Growth stage (Series B+)Every 12 months, and before every corporate action
Pre-IPO12–18 months before listing, then quarterly
Granting ESOPsYearly
Bank loan collateralYearly for stressed accounts, every 3 years for standard
M&A targetWhen the deal starts
Industrial insuranceYearly for fast-inflating assets, or every 2–3 years
Ind AS reportingYearly for goodwill tests; at every business combination
IBC / CIRPAs soon as CIRP starts

What is the bottom line?

Valuation does more than set a price. It drives growth, investment and compliance. The same company can have different values for different purposes, and all can be correct. Getting the purpose right first is what makes a report hold up.

Need help applying these rules to your business? Talk to a valuation expert at RNC, or see our business valuation services.

Frequently asked questions

Does the purpose change the value?

It can. A valuation for insurance, for tax and for a sale may each use a different basis of value. So state the purpose at the start.

Who should do a mandatory valuation?

Use an IBBI-registered valuer in the right asset class. Where the rule asks for one, use a SEBI-registered merchant banker.

Sources and standards

The regulators and standard setters whose rules apply to this topic. Rules change, so check the current text before relying on it.

Get a quote

Request a valuation proposal

Tell us what needs valuing and why. You will hear back from a partner, not a sales desk.

  • Scoped proposal with fee and timeline, usually within one business day
  • Conflict check and NDA before any data changes hands
  • Reports signed under IBBI registration IBBI/RV-E/02/2020/123

Tell us about the assignment

Takes under a minute. All fields help us scope accurately.

    Service interested in *

    Your details stay confidential and are used only to prepare your proposal.